What are the arguments against adoption?

In this blog post, we will answer the question “what are the arguments against adoption?” We begin with factors that argue against adoption, discuss the possible reasons behind giving children up for adoption is, and finally end with discussing the possible long-term effects of adoption. 

What are the arguments against adoption? 

We all bring something different to the table when it comes to adoption, and our conclusions are frequently the result of a number of factors that impact adoption even before the journey begins.

Raising adoption concerns can only lead to a plethora of differing viewpoints or contentious issues, not only about adoption but about all adoption-related issues. 

Adoption may represent a lot of things to different people. For others, it means a family, love, and a chance at a happy life. Others consider adoption to be immoral, unlawful, destructive, and fraught with dangers. 

Of course, no two adoption cases are the same, just like most other life-altering and life-changing events. We all bring something unique to the table when it comes to adoption, and our conclusions are frequently the result of a complex set of factors that impact adoption well before the journey begins.

Neither side is likely to concede anytime soon, but the truth is that millions of youngsters throughout the world are suffering from or will confront the agonizing predicament of loneliness at some point in the future, regardless of the reason. 

And, regardless of which side you are on, most people will agree that every kid deserves to be loved by a family, and that if being in a biological family isn’t in the child’s best interests, foster care is the solution.

Choosing between private and foster care is a difficult decision to make

While some families favor foster care adoption, others prefer private adoption. 

Some proponents of foster care adoption will vehemently argue that adopting babies through a private adoption agency is selfish when there are so many aged children in foster care, not to mention the nearly $0 cost. 

Rather of waiting for children to discover them more readily, agents and attorneys pay less for possible adoptive families and perform private adoptions. 

Indeed, the waiting lists for children in need of foster care are extensive, and it might be perplexing why someone would spend so much money and wait for a long list to be made private.

It’s frightening to think about how many years, months, weeks, or even days you’ll go without knowing where your child will sleep or who will care for them tomorrow. Foster care, however, can be intimidating for some families. 

Young families who are unprepared to care for children with special mental or emotional needs, young families who have experienced neglect or abuse by members of their biological family, and the consequences and expectations of an unstable system as they move from foster home to foster home are all examples.

Other adoptive families are unprepared for open adoption, which frequently occurs when a child is placed with an adoptive family. 

While there has been substantial studies showing that open adoption is in the best interests of the kid, some claim that open adoption is confusing and may be hazardous to children in some circumstances, and that it may lower the likelihood of the adopted child being close to the adopted child. family.

Domestic vs. Foreign

Adoption outside of a town, state, or nation may not be the best decision for some people. 

“When there are so many kids here, why do you adopt children from other countries?” This is a crucial point, and it is undoubtedly correct. 

Hundreds of thousands of children aged 8 to 21 (in some areas) are waiting in lengthy lines to be adopted into a permanent, stable home in the United States’ foster care system. 

These children, according to proponents of home adoption, must come first. UNICEF, on the other hand, believes that there are 153 million orphans in the globe. 

These children have a greater death rate due to child labor, starvation, and conflict, in addition to the fact that they are in need of homes.

Borders aren’t a barrier or a justification for some foster families to refuse to offer a loving home to children in need, and regardless of zip code, all children deserve equal opportunity.

Some people believe that foreign adoption is detrimental to children’s welfare. 

Human trafficking is connected to inter-adoption, according to opponents, placing children at danger of kidnapping (or, under the guise of being separated from their birth family), sexual abuse, and enslavement.

While there have been verified incidences of child abuse and adoption on a global scale, there are protections in place to dissuade and protect offenders on both a national and international level. 

The Hague Convention, according to www.travel.state.gov.com, is an international agreement that assures international adoption while protecting the rights of children, biological families, and prospective adoptees. It came into force in the United States on April 1, 2008.

Families that are adopting internationally. Families should work with reputable international adoption agencies and make sure that all parties involved (domestic and foreign) are aware of the requirements and follow them. 

There are several excellent international adoption organizations and orphanages dedicated to putting children in loving and permanent families.

Race/ Ethnicity

Interracial adoption has been the subject of discussion for as long as interracial adoption has existed. Some people feel that inter-racial adoption puts children in risk. 

How can it be in a kid’s best interest to adopt a child of a different race and send him to a house on the opposite side of the school district, where he will stand out among his classmates, let alone take him home? 

The tale of her birth nation, told by individuals who looked and sounded like her. Adoptions that involve moving from one culture or nation to another are complicated, and people who are open to interracial adoption are fully aware of the issues.

In today’s world, prospective adoptive parents must be educated and taught on race concerns and the complications of interracial adoption. 

Many mixed-race families join support organizations so that their children do not feel alone or unusual. It may seem reasonable to disregard disparities in skin color, physical shape, and culture, yet it is harmful to the adopted kid. 

Listening to your child’s worries and ensuring that he or she feels secure in their identity and everything that comes with it is critical to their self-esteem. 

Families that are open to adopting children of other races should make sure they have the support and resources they need before doing so, and they should understand that “seeing color” has nothing to do with how others see them.

What are the reasons why children are put up for adoption?

Adoption of children for a number of reasons. Because their children are teens, many women put them up for adoption. 

It’s possible that their parents are the ones forcing them to give up their children for adoption. 

A teenager, for example, may become pregnant at an early age, and her parents may not feel that she is capable of caring for a kid. Because their mother was raped, many children give up on adoption.

Adoption is the most common way for single parents to give up their children. They will not be able to raise a child on their own in this situation. 

It makes no difference whether you’re a guy or a woman in that circumstance; if one of you is unable to nurture a kid, you must make the difficult decision to abandon adoption.

Adoption and Adoptees’ Long-Term Effects

Many adoptees have had a happy experience with adoption, however, some have had unpleasant experiences with their children as a result of adoption.

Persistent mental or emotional trauma is a possibility.

Adoption can have a detrimental impact on the mental and emotional health of a child for certain people. Child adoption may have the following psychological effects:

  • Confronted by Self-Esteem is a term used to describe someone who has a low opinion of
  • Anxiety over where you “fit in” or identity issues
  • Emotional bonds are difficult to build
  • Anger or bereavement over a biological family member

Although these negative consequences of adoption on children may be temporary, they tend to arise and vanish irregularly throughout the adoptee’s life. 

Frequently at times of major life events or emotional turmoil. If you’re coping with these unpleasant psychological or emotional effects of adoption, it can be beneficial to speak with a therapist who has dealt with adoption-related difficulties before.

Adoptees in closed adoptions face a lack of information

Adopted individuals are concerned about the lack of information available to them in private adoptions. 

Despite the fact that practically all adoptions are now open, many adult adoptees are still dealing with the negative repercussions of adoption brought on by the closed adoption era. 

The following are some of the difficulties:

  • Adoptees and their children have a difficult time diagnosing health concerns due to a lack of medical or social history. 
  • It’s unclear where they got their physical or mental characteristics from. 
  • There is no explanation for why they stopped adopting. 
  • When an adopted becomes an adult and wants to contact his birth family, it might be difficult to locate them since they have little or no information about them.
  • If only one could identify a biological family, it would be an emotionally painful reunion.

Although these negative repercussions of adult adoption are unpleasant and frustrating, increasing openness to adoption might help future generations avoid them.

Adoption is subjective.

There are no subjective arguments in favor or against it. It’s not for you as an individual or as a parent. Every task is different depending on who you are and what you are capable of.

This is for you if you can be really open and selfless, and you agree that your child will always have another family member that cares. 

This is for you if you can accept that there will always be unfathomable disparities between you and your child. This is for you if you want to make someone’s life better.

But you’re wrong if you want him to be exactly like you and adopt him. You may be correct in some aspects, but you will be incorrect in many others, and the scenario will not meet your expectations.

They’re unique, yet you’ll adore them as if they were yours…because they are, in a sense. It’s just unique. It’s also a bit of a tangle. You should be able to do it well as well.

References: 

  1. https://adoption.com/4-controversial-topics-surrounding-adoption/#:~:text=Some%20people%20fear%20that%20international,%2C%20sexual%20abuse%2C%20and%20slavery.
  2. https://www.hellomotherhood.com/how-to-find-a-child-you-gave-up-for-adoption-4106433.html 

What was missing from this post which could have made it better?